Answer

How to choose an SEO company.

How to choose an SEO company comes down to a few questions and how the firm answers them. Google publishes some of those questions. We add the ones about ownership and leaving.

How to choose an SEO company.
Sources
  1. 1How do I choose an SEO company?
  2. 2What questions does Google say to ask an SEO?
  3. 3What answer should end the meeting?
  4. 4How does BitMap Media answer those questions?
  5. 5How to choose an SEO company: the statistics
  6. 6Questions about how to choose an SEO company

Key takeaways: how to choose an SEO company

  • How do I choose an SEO company? Ask about past work, time in business, experience in your industry, expected results and timeframe. Then ask who owns the accounts and what happens if you leave.
  • What should end the meeting? A guarantee. Google says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking, and to find someone else if a firm promises first place.
  • What is the most overlooked question? Who holds the logins. The domain, hosting and Business Profile should be in your name.
  • How does BitMap Media answer? No guarantees, published prices, accounts in your name and a full export within five business days if you leave.
Four questions Google says to ask an SEO: examples of previous work, time in business

How do I choose an SEO company?

Choose on answers, not on promises. Ask each firm the same questions, write the answers down and compare them. A firm that is vague about ownership, price or reporting before you sign will be vague after.

Compare answers before hiring

Google reminds owners that they are responsible for the actions of any company they hire. That is the reason to take the choice slowly.

It also says to be wary of SEO firms and web consultants that email you out of the blue.

That is how to choose an SEO company without relying on a sales pitch. Knowing how to choose an SEO company mostly comes down to how plainly a firm answers.

What questions does Google say to ask an SEO?

Google lists several, including whether the firm can show examples of previous work and success stories, how long it has been in business, what its experience is in your industry, and what results it expects in what timeframe.

Google's suggested interview questions

The full list is in Do you need an SEO? on Google Search Central.

We keep a longer list of our own. Fifteen questions to ask before you hire anyone includes four we would prefer you did not ask us, which is why they are there.

Google does not tell you how to choose an SEO company. It tells you what to ask.

A comparison of reassuring answers and warning-sign answers from an SEO company

What answer should end the meeting?

Any guarantee of a ranking. Google states that no one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google, and that if a firm guarantees first place in search results, you should find someone else.

Promises and ownership red flags

Two more answers are worth walking away from. One is a firm that wants the domain, hosting or Business Profile in its own name. The other is a firm that cannot show a real monthly report with the client name removed.

Knowing how to choose an SEO company includes knowing when to leave the room.

How BitMap Media answers four hard questions: guarantees, ownership, price and leaving

How to choose an SEO company: the statistics

Ahrefs polled 439 SEO providers around the world. It published the survey on 12-17-2023 and updated it on 08-15-2024, so prices in the US today may differ.

Statistics last updated 11-15-2026. Each figure links to the organization that first published it.

  • 78.2% of the SEO providers in Ahrefs' pricing survey charge a monthly retainer. Source: Ahrefs, 2024.
  • The most common monthly retainer in Ahrefs' pricing survey is $501 to $1,000, charged by 20.4% of the providers. Source: Ahrefs, 2024.

Questions about how to choose an SEO company

How do I pick a good SEO company?

Look for straight answers on four things: guarantees, ownership, price and reporting. A good firm answers all four before you sign.

Should an SEO company publish its prices?

Not necessarily, but a refusal to give a number before a discovery call is worth noticing. We publish ours.

Is it a warning sign if an SEO company contacts me first?

Google says to be wary of SEO firms and web consultants that email you out of the blue.

What should I own if I leave an SEO company?

The domain, the hosting, the Business Profile and the content, including drafts. Our guide to who owns your website covers each one.

Will the SEO company write my content with AI?

Most will. The real question is who checks it. We draft with AI and a marketer checks every page against eight published points.

BitMap Media editorial team
Reviewed and curated by the BitMap Media team
Marketers with decades across print, TV, direct mail, email, web, video and CRM. Updated 11-15-2026. About the team

Start with what a machine can read about your business.

The free AI Visibility Score checks eight points on your live site. It needs only your website address, and it tells you where you stand before you hire anyone.

Get your Free AI Visibility Score