How to tell if your SEO company is working.
How to tell if your SEO company is working: read one document, the monthly report. If there is no report, or it is all charts and no explanation, you have part of your answer.
Sources
Key takeaways: how to tell if your SEO company is working
- How do I tell if my SEO company is working? Read the monthly report. It should say what was done, what moved, what did not move and what happens next.
- Are rankings the right measure? Not alone. No firm controls rankings, so judge the work you can see: pages published, fixes made, searches and clicks in Search Console.
- Is a flat month a bad sign? No. Flat months happen to everyone. The bad sign is a firm that never reports one.
- What does BitMap Media send? One report a month in plain language, with the work done and the numbers from your own accounts.
How do I tell if my SEO company is working?
Ask for last month in writing: what the firm did, what changed and what it plans next. An SEO company that is working can answer that without preparation, because it is already in the report.
Verify reported work
Google's guide, Do you need an SEO?, says to ask a firm what results it expects and in what timeframe. The report is where you hold it to that answer. Then check the work against the site. If the report says two posts were published, they should be on the site. If it says pages were fixed, the pages should read differently.
The numbers should come from accounts you can open yourself, such as Google Search Console. Our guide on how to read Search Console explains what the figures mean.
If you searched "how to tell if your SEO company is working", start here: ask for last month in writing.
What should a monthly SEO report show?
Work and results, kept separate. The work is what the firm controlled: content, fixes, updates. The results are what followed: searches, clicks, calls. A report that shows only one of them hides the other.
Separate activity from outcomes
Ask to see a real report from another client with the name removed. A sample dashboard or a screenshot proves little, because both are easy to build.
A report should also be readable. Ours is written in plain language, so you do not need a marketing dictionary to follow it.
A report like that is how to tell if your SEO company is working and what it is working on. A report nobody can read will not show you how to tell if your SEO company is working.
What should happen in a month when nothing improves?
The firm should tell you, and say what it will do next. Flat months happen to everyone. An agency that claims it never has one is probably reporting selectively.
Honest reporting through flat months
Some of it is outside anyone's control. Agencies cannot decide when a site is crawled and indexed. They can have the site ready for when it happens.
So judge a flat month by the honesty of the report and the quality of the plan. That is how to tell if your SEO company is working when the numbers are not moving.
A firm that reports a flat month honestly is easier to trust.
What does BitMap Media report each month?
One report a month in plain language. It covers the 300+ point scan of the site, the two new posts, the SEO work, updates and backups, and what the numbers did.
Monthly report contents and terms
The report is part of Monthly Care and SEO at $1295 a month, flat. The plan is month to month, so if the reports stop making sense you can leave with thirty days written notice and no fee.
With one report a month, you know how to tell if your SEO company is working without guessing.
How to tell if your SEO company is working: the statistics
Position on the page decides most of the clicks, which is why a report should show where your pages rank.
Statistics last updated 11-15-2026. Each figure links to the organization that first published it.
- The #1 organic result in Google has an average click-through rate of 27.6%, according to Backlinko's study of about 4 million search results. Source: Backlinko, 2025.
- In the same Backlinko study, the #1 result had about 10 times the click-through rate of the #10 result. Source: Backlinko, 2025.
- Only 0.63% of searchers clicked a result on Google's second page in Backlinko's study. Source: Backlinko, 2025.
Questions about how to tell if your SEO company is working
How long before SEO shows results?
Google's guide gives no timeframe. It tells you to ask the firm what results it expects, and when. We give none either, because nobody controls how long crawling and indexing takes.
Should my rankings go up every month?
No. Rankings move in both directions, and no firm controls them. Look at the trend and at the work done.
What if my SEO company will not share a report?
Treat it as an answer. A firm doing the work has a record of it.
Can I check the numbers myself?
Yes, if the accounts are in your name. Google Search Console shows the searches and clicks for your site.
Is your SEO company helping your business if calls have not increased?
Not yet, and it should say so. Ask what it will change, then see whether next month's report follows through.
Start with what a machine can read about your business.
The free AI Visibility Score checks eight points on your live site. It needs only your website address, and it tells you where you stand before you hire anyone.
Get your Free AI Visibility Score