Answer

Fifteen questions to ask before you hire anyone, including us.

Each one has an answer that should reassure you and an answer that should end the meeting. Four of them are questions we would rather you did not ask, which is why they are here.

Fifteen questions to ask before you hire anyone, including us.
Sources
  1. 1The four we would rather you did not ask
  2. 2Questions to ask about scope and ownership
  3. 3What should I ask about measurement and reporting?
  4. 4Risk, and the three answers that should end a meeting
  5. 5More on choosing an agency

Key takeaways: questions to ask an SEO agency

  • What is the single best question? “What do I own, and how quickly can I take it, if I leave in six months?” The answer reveals how the whole relationship is structured, and nobody rehearses it.
  • What answer should end a meeting? Any guarantee. If an agency promises you a ranking position, a spot in an AI answer, or a result by a date, end the meeting. Nobody controls those systems. There are no guarantees in search, and we do not offer them.
  • Should prices be published? Not necessarily, but a refusal to give a number before a discovery call is worth noticing. We publish ours, which is our position; it is not an industry rule.
  • What is the most overlooked question? Who holds the logins. Plenty of businesses find out they do not own their own domain or Business Profile at the exact moment they try to leave.
Questions to ask an agency before you hire them

The four we would rather you did not ask

These are the ones with teeth. They are uncomfortable for any agency, including this one, which is the reason to lead with them.

They are the first questions to ask an SEO agency, because they are the hardest to dodge. Any SEO agency that answers them plainly has little to hide. We list them among the questions to ask because we would want to know the answers ourselves. Good questions to ask an SEO agency have one thing in common: a vague answer tells you something.

  • If I leave in six months, what do I own, and how fast can I have it? You want a specific list and a timescale. A vague answer, or a pause, usually means the exit has never been designed. Ours is a full export within five business days, including credentials, schema files and the content.
  • Whose name is on the domain, the hosting and the Google Business Profile? It should be yours, with them as a manager. If any of the three is in their name, you are renting your own business identity. See who owns your website.
  • What happens in a month when nothing improves? Flat months happen to everyone. What you are listening for is whether they will tell you, and what they do next. An agency that has never had a flat month is an agency that reports selectively. Agencies have zero control over when your site is crawled and indexed, but they can have you ready for when it happens.
  • Can I see a real monthly report from one of your clients? With the client name removed. A sample dashboard or a screenshot proves nothing, because both are easy to build. A real report shows what was done that month, what moved, what did not move, and what happens next. Ours is written in plain language, so you can read it without a marketing dictionary.

Questions to ask about scope and ownership

  • What exactly is in the price, and what is quoted separately? You want the second list to exist and be short. "Everything is included" usually means the boundaries have not been thought about yet.
  • Who does the work? The person in the meeting, a team, or a subcontractor. Any of the three can be fine. Not knowing which is not.
  • Will you write content with AI? Most will. The real question is who checks it and against what. We draft with AI and a marketer checks every page against eight published points before it goes out, and we say so. We do not imply everything is hand-typed.
  • Who owns the content if we part company? It should be you, outright, including the drafts.

What should I ask about measurement and reporting?

Four questions: what the first report will look like, where the numbers come from, how they measure AI visibility, and what they change when something is not working. Ask to see a real report with the client name removed, and listen for the method behind the numbers, which a screenshot will not show you.

These are the questions to ask an SEO agency before the first report arrives. The best questions to ask about reporting are the ones with a checkable answer. A good SEO agency will show you where each number comes from. If an SEO agency cannot answer these, treat that as the answer. Keep this list of questions to ask an SEO agency beside you on the call.

  • What will the first report look like? Ask to see a real one with the client name removed. A sample that is all green charts and no commentary is a template.
  • Where do your numbers come from? Search Console and analytics are your own data. A tool's estimated traffic is a model. Both are useful; you must always be told which is which.
  • How do you measure AI visibility? Listen for a method: an agreed question set, run on a schedule, recorded with dates. If the answer is a single screenshot of an assistant naming them, that is one sample from a system that varies by person and location.
  • What do you change when something is not working? A good answer names something specific: a page rewritten, a different set of questions tracked, a tactic dropped. We go through the numbers with you every month and say what we are changing before you have to ask.
Questions to ask an agency, and the answers that should end a meeting: guarantees

More on choosing an agency

Is a bigger agency safer?

Different risks, not fewer. Larger firms have cover when someone is away and process behind the work; smaller ones give you the person who actually does it. What matters more than size is whether the person answering your questions is the person doing the work.

Should I pay monthly or per project?

Per project for building something, monthly for keeping it alive and improving it. Some monthly fees are really a build being paid off in installments, so it is worth asking what happens at month four if you stop. Ours are kept separate: the build is quoted and invoiced on its own, and the monthly plan is month to month with no cancellation fee.

What if I already have an agency, and I am unsure?

Ask them the ownership question and the reporting question from this list. Both are reasonable for any client to ask, and the reaction tells you a great deal. A good agency answers them in a sentence each.

How long before I see results?

For technical and profile fixes, often weeks. For content and authority, months. Anyone giving you a confident date for a ranking is guessing, and the specific trap is a short contract sold on a timeline that the work cannot meet.

Do I need to understand SEO to manage an agency?

No, but you need to be able to tell work from activity. Every question on this page is answerable without technical knowledge, and the reports you get should be too. If you cannot understand the report, ask for a different report. The fault is not yours.

Why would you publish questions that could cost you the sale?

Because the clients we lose on those questions were going to be unhappy anyway, and because a buyer who asks them is a buyer who knows what they are getting. It is the same reason our prices are published and custom projects are quoted.

BitMap Media editorial team
Reviewed and curated by the BitMap Media team
Marketers with decades across print, TV, direct mail, email, web, video and CRM. Updated 10-30-2026. About the team

Ask us anything on this list.

Or start with the free AI Visibility Score, which tells you what your site needs before anyone quotes you for fixing it.

Get your Free AI Visibility Score